Dear organizers, I am Tsai-Min Chen, on behalf of team Metformin-121. Thanks for your preparation for the Winners Announcement. However, we noticed that there is an inaccurate result about our submission. The 2 separate models we submitted should be named after **Final_modelS** and **Final_modelSS**, but none of them appears in your final results announcement; instead, the model name of our Midpoint Benchmark submission, **modelC**, appears: ``` Rank Team/Model Overall Outliers Sev1: Est (CI✓) / Outliers Sev2: Est (CI✓) / Outliers Sev3: Est (CI✓) / Outliers Total Deviation 🥇 1st Team Luc - Model 2 43% 1.21 ✓ / 13% 0.86 ✓ / 12% 0.82 ✗ / 19% 0.24 🥈 2nd Team Luc - Model 3 45% 1.18 ✓ / 13% 0.89 ✓ / 14% 0.82 ✗ / 19% 0.26 🥉 3rd Metformin-121 Model C 55% 1.65 ✗ / 29% 0.76 ✓ / 21% 0.74 ✓ / 5% 0.62 4th Base Age Model 59% 2.20 ✗ / 31% 0.72 ✓ / 22% 0.74 ✓ / 6% 1.20 *✓ = Within 95% CI ✗ = Outside 95% CI Outliers = Bootstrap instability percentage Total Deviation = Sum of absolute differences from RCT point estimates* ``` Could you please help us check what's going on here? After all, we have confirmed that both **Final_modelS** and **Final_modelSS** were received correctly and scored valid by @scottie from previous discussion Thread: **Final submission instructions**. Sincerely yours, Tsai-Min

Created by TSAI-MIN (在民) CHEN (陳) chentsaimin
Dear organizers, Thanks for your help and clarification. We have confirmed that Model C was also submitted by us for final evaluation. It's our fault that we forgot it; therefore, your Winners Announcement is correct. Sorry for your troubles. Sincerely yours, Tsai-Min
Hello Tsai-Min, Thank you for participating in the challenge and for your question. We included Model C as each team was allowed to submit up to three final models. Final_modelS (62% outlier bootstraps) and Final_modelSS (62% outlier bootstraps) did not yield results that outperformed Model C. If you would prefer we exclude Model C, we can update the results to only consider Final_modelS and Final_modelSS. However, please note that only Model C outperformed the Base Age Model. I hope this answers your question. Best, Erick

(solved)[Results] Missreporting the models for Performance Analysis using NIH IMPACC Cohort Study Data in Winners Announcement page is loading…